You didn't narrow your argument to net contributors or rich people.
You're perfectly happy with construction workers being turned away, just not rich people.
That's fair. Then we can skip the "I'm a net contributor" argument and jump to "I'm a large net contributor".
So we are very foolish for not having open borders for at least rich people?
Let's say everyone who makes over $200k in the US is permitted to live here. Does that negatively effect the market conditions for anyone in the country?
Then the argument becomes so what if it does negatively effect some people. What right do they have to live here simply by virtue of being born here or immigrating earlier? We're all just humans, it's stolen land, etc.