Second, 17% is a lot of dealerships. I mean, I presume that these are the dealerships that aren't selling all that many cars, but... what total sales volume did they account for. 5%? 10%? Does Cadillac want to lose that much of their total sales? Do they want to pay money to lose that much of their total sales?
And, really, pay $300,000 for a dealership to go away, because the dealership wouldn't pay $200,000 for a charging station. Why not, you know, put up the $200,000, and keep the dealership?
For instance I consulted a group of Ford dealerships, only one of which had a Lincoln franchise. To keep the Lincoln brand they needed to do stuff like have a separate branded entrance and minumum floorspace for the Lincoln side of things, etc. At some point it’s not worth it if 95% of your revenue comes from selling the mainline brand.
$176 million is different than $20 million. And that's not the only cost the dealers are incurring including reduced revenue from land that could be used to sell cars.
Is a franchise something that a dealer has to purchase up front? If so, maybe it's sort of like property, and Cadillac has to buy it back from them? I believe at least the first part is how some e.g. restaurant franchises work.