> "try to buy them all"
buy all of AWS's? Then: no, it would cost less.
buy from open market? Then: yes, It would cost more
If you go into a market and try to buy lots of something, it drives the price up because you're increasing demand and removing supply.
If you go into a market and try to sell lots of something, it drives the price down because you're increasing supply and removing demand.
AWS don't obviously have an incentive to sell IP addresses for substantially below market value, so I don't see why buying them from AWS versus someone else would make much difference.
You just invalided yourself. What do you think my point is?
The point I was trying to make is that just because the IPv4 addresses are valued at $2B doesn't mean you'd be able to buy them for $2B.