Why do you consider it a hit piece? The main allegation that illegal content was on PornHub is based on facts, right?
More generally, the question is if a porn-site that allows anyone to upload stuff should be legally viable. You may feel that it should not. But make no mistake, Laila Mickelwait wants to shutdown the porn industry, not improve Pornhub.
There seem to be no strong evidence that Pornhub did remove illegal content they became aware of.
It's delusional to think that Pornhub did not know about this content. They only cared when the credit card companies threatened to withhold payments.
Either the technology didn't work, or the claims were false. Either way, Pornhub knew that they were hosting these videos. They just didn't care.