* Robinhood took a bigger slice of the pie than the other brokerages did.
* Robinhood claimed in marketing materials that they were not taking more of the pie.
* Even factoring in the fee savings, Robinhood took so much of the pie that you'd get a better deal at other brokerages.
The issue on HN is always going to be a litigation about PFOF itself. But that's not the SEC's complaint here; rather, it's that when you enter into a PFOF rebate deal, you dial in profits for yourself against savings for customers. Everybody does that, but Robinhood both (1) turned the dial way towards themselves and (2) claimed otherwise.
The entire industry as some may know is built on 'do your homework' and 'hold long term' is basically a big shared delusion gamble.
The majority of people will make money if the market goes up and lose money if the market goes down.