Robinhood is more expensive than commissioned brokers, it just hides the charges better.
Which do you think is more expensive for the customer:
1. $0.003 per share of inferior execution on a retail order of 50 shares.
2. A $9.99 commission.
Assuming they have multiple hidden revenue sources, that 9.99$ commission could be up to ~4 orders of magnitude cheaper.
So, sure the article is talking about one specific means their using, but that’s hardly the only option they have. Remember the best conmen run multi layered con’s, as people finding the first layer and trying to profit from it are the easiest marks.
The OP complained that with the benefit of hindsight the options went up in value after being sold, but given that all retail traders are degenerate gamblers with zero actual alpha there was a 50/50 chance the options could have gone in the entirely opposite direction, and selling them early could just as easily have saved the commenter thousands of dollars.
If closing early generates more profit then they don’t win or lose, just executing the trade at close for the customer.
However, if waiting generates more profit then they can always say they executed early while waiting and then pocket the difference.
They could even even pick a mid point at time X, then compare some random time period before and after the transaction looking for a hypothetical less profitable execution time.
Do you have an explanation that doesn't involve making up wild, evidence-free conspiracy theories? I can claim that Robinhood secretly makes most of their revenue from selling their users to human traffickers if I want, but that's not an actual reasonable criticism of their business model.
Anyway, the existence or not of this policy is kind of secondary to the idea that indirect profit can be more expensive to the users. Clearly they need to be generating some revenue, and if you don’t know where it is that’s often a very bad deal. 401k hidden fees for example can sometimes exceed the tax savings.
You were willing to pay $100, so from your point of view you weren't "harmed" either way, but with the traditional broker you saved $2/share, and with Robinhood all the savings went to them.
Generally, brokers are either required to go with the best offer, or, if they don't, explain to customers that they don't and why. Robinhood violated that rule by marketing themselves and going with the best offers (but actually did the opposite) and that's what the SEC is fining them for.