This is corrected. I believe the Nintendo 64 was released a month before NiGHTS Into Dreams and the Saturn analog controller debuted
Sure, but the Saturn's short, stubby analog stick was better designed than the N64 one.
Going by that criteria then I'd give the nod to Sony. Their dual analog sticks was really the game changer and has gone on to be the standard.
And being pedantic the Atari 5200 had an analog controller long before them. Not that it was any good, mind you, since it was bizarrely non-self-centering.