The irony of the BMI is the more I workout to stay in the healthy range, the more difficult it is to stay in the healthy range. Best bet is to sit around not eating anything to be 'healthy' according to BMI.
It's not like weightlifting is something only few men can do; most men can weightlift. Then they end up having healthy body fat levels, but end up with BMI in the overweight category. If something as simple and straightforward as weightlifting messes up a measure, then it's not a good measure.
This guy is strong as hell but he isn't healthy at all https://youtu.be/1LsIQr_4iSY
You are arguing that if it empirically works for most people, then it’s a good measure. I’m saying that a good measure should in principle work for most people.