We know because we got the merit increase. Do you think they'd give up so easily if they had a good case against it?
It's not like it's in the best interest of the workers to see the company go belly up. Or be less competitive. If the company can show that this is why they're defering merit pay there's no reason to believe that unions won't accept it and agree with them.
It gives employees leverage, and healthy competition in all aspects should just strengthen the company.
There's a real consideration of whether X% of employee compensation over N years is better than the same over M years.
So they kicked the can down the road and chose 1 until they just went bankrupt and the courts allowed contracts to be renegotiated and high cost union employees to be replaced with younger employees at a far lower compensation package.