I've cut down my caffeine intake, but frankly I don't see any real benefit in quitting entirely. I take one caffeine pill in the morning and another at noon. It's so much easier and cheaper than drinking coffee (less than $10 for an entire month), and unlike coffee or tea, it doesn't stain my teeth! My sleep seems fine, since I don't take any caffeine later in the day, but the dosage is still sufficient to maintain my "addiction" without withdrawal symptoms.
The only downside is the rare occasion when I forget to take caffeine at noon. This happened once a couple months ago, and it made me feel like complete crap, the equivalent of a bad hangover, until I took caffeine again. The experience reinforced my feeling that quitting "cold turkey" is never worth it. Who has a whole week, or even days to spare to be miserable and unproductive? Should I take a "vacation" for that?
Obviously it would have been preferable to not become addicted to caffeine in the first place. I blame graduate school for that. But given the fact that I am addicted, it seems to be a relatively harmless addiction compared to most others.
I think of caffeine now explicitly as addiction maintenance. I only take it on a schedule and don't use it as an alertness aid. The latter is the dangerous path leading to increased dosages and diminishing returns. I just take a minimum regular dosage to avoid withdrawal symptoms.