It is a neat idea, but the purist in me misses those <p> tags, even though they are the main reason why I don't like writing HTML by hand.
But for every paragraph I write I need to type <p> (and maybe even </p>, if I choose to).
That's exactly the use case for Markdown, to get rid of that tedious stuff.
Look, I don't hate hand-written HTML. I actually like it better than Markdown.
And I have zero idea why you all insist that I must love writing HTML.
Leave me alone!
Edit: Actually, seems you're right. Though doctype is not there, and there are other problems with the markup.
The smallest valid HTML document is:
<!DOCTYPE html><title>…</title>
If you put that into the validator, you will see that it is valid.