And if other ISP's refuse to peer with you?
Maybe we need another kind of law, above and beyond 230, requiring large ISP's and cloud providers to act as common carriers in exchange for certain protections.
I don't have a fixed concept on the details here, it's just an idea I had.
Think about this: Does Google have a legal or moral right (or responsibility) to delete emails calling for specific and actionable violence against someone? Or is email too private for that?
This is the rathole we're in. If someone does plan over gmail, does all of gmail get shut down? What about the ISP that served it? If someone plans a violent attack over the phone, does a company's phone network get shutdown?
How far are we willing to go for our rights and privacy?
What you're talking about it preemptively policing and taking actions. I'm sure politicians would love that but we're not there (yet).
I don't think that's true. Hurricane Electric for example is a major provider and the AUP [0] only prohibits illegal and/or technically damaging behaviour.
Some of the others have language like that in their AUPs but it doesn't seem to be universal.
To be fair, I think most reasonable people would say sub points #6 and #7 seem pretty fair, at least on the face of it they do to me. But what one person considers a threat another considers banter and hence we have scenarios where people can easy run afoul of some morality judgement by an employee or exec at the company. It doesn't have to be as blatant as a death threat it could be some banter via an innuendo and suddenly they ban your account. Sure, you can sue, argue your point, but either way your business would be offline. Just the first part I quoted, all they have to say is your content or users affect their legal interests in some way and again subjective and your done.