And if other ISP's refuse to peer with you?
Maybe we need another kind of law, above and beyond 230, requiring large ISP's and cloud providers to act as common carriers in exchange for certain protections.
I don't have a fixed concept on the details here, it's just an idea I had.
Think about this: Does Google have a legal or moral right (or responsibility) to delete emails calling for specific and actionable violence against someone? Or is email too private for that?