What erosion of civil discourse are you talking about? 10 years ago half or more Americans were against gay marriage, today 30% of the US is against that, except nowadays they are also called neonazis and are being deplatformed from major platforms. Do you think 50 years ago there could be civil discourse on legalizing rape or celebrating Holocaust? No, these people would get the same treatment. Or, as a non-imaginary example, just remember McCarthyism.
What changed is the level of discrepancy of Overton windows between rural and urban America. That’s all.
> platforms being used to organize illegal activities
Hah, but when they are used to organize illegal activities in countries like Egypt or Belarus it was not an issue.
> proliferation of misinformation (during a pandemic)
If you think that an average citizen is too stupid to think for themselves, we might as well just abolish voting rights. And surely there is a better way to combat misinformation than giving censorship powers to private technocrats.