> In the past, I have made no secret of my disdain for Chef Gusteau’s famous motto: Anyone can cook. But I realize, only now do I truly understand what he meant. Not everyone can become a great artist, but a great artist can come from anywhere. It is difficult to imagine more humble origins than those of the genius now cooking at Gusteau’s, who is, in this critic’s opinion, nothing less than the finest chef in France. I will be returning to Gusteau’s soon, hungry for more.
It isn't at all clear that this is true. A lot of real advances are made by a largish collection of people plugging away and sharing ideas. We really love the narrative around the archetype of a lone inventor, but it's rarely that clear cut. This is exacerbated by the incentive structures - we want to pick "winners".
This isn't to say that there aren't people who really stand out, far from it. But it's probably a mistake to account too much progress to them.
Education gets diluted the more people are educated. Think about how much you learn in university in a short time compared to how much you learn in school.
Now imagine you would have gone to school only with the ones who finished university. How much more would you have learned during that time?
Then imagine a fully equipped university that isn't filled with rich kids but with the brightest.
Think of Katalin Karikó[1]. We don't trust the degrees because everybody can get one nowadays. That's why established figures in a field decide what is worthwhile to research instead of giving that responsibility to the ones who have proven that they can think for themselves.
Who's gonna pay for it?
Commoditization of education so brightest kids can get the best of it is a net benefit to the industry.
But as long as industry is filled with dumbfuck MBAs it won't happen.
No legacy admissions. No quotas. Large populations trying to get in through entrance exams and school performance?
(Lots of rich kids wind up at those places, but they have worked for it)
I agree that have no way to tell ahead of time. That said, I don't think this works like buying a lot of lottery tickets. A breakthrough isn't random, even if it is unpredictable. It also isn't just a function of who the scientist inherently is. Circumstances may be the bigger half of the equation.
If a patent clerk shows up with relativity, there is no shortage of places that will provide him a desk and some pencils. Newton emerged out of aristocracy, as did Darwin and many others. Tenured professorships are/were an attempt to replicate those circumstances in many ways. Einstein came out of a patent clerk job. In today's terms this is a wfh with lots of bullshit time. We have a lot of math educated people today with these circumstances.
It's just a really hard question.. how do we get more "one offs." IIRC pg named it black swan farming. "Employ" is a broad term and I suspect how its defined matters here.
These are not the sort of people you would give a job too, either, because they were basically unpleasant and unreliable in everyday life.
I think a better way of framing it is that people with some talent will emerge naturally no matter their circumstances
A whole lot of things are like this.