* Better party hour transport availability
* Better driver awareness, education, and propaganda
* More enforcement of drunk suspects before an accident
* Police cooperation with bars, i.e. tattle-tail programs
Moving to America I’m astonished how much drunk driving goes unpunished here. In rural areas there people often go a few dozen km to the next bar, and there is no alternative to get home except to drive. When there is enforcement it seems like it is only over the top punishment. Bartenders seem to be fine with people having a few beers and driving home (as long as they are not “too drunk”).
I think America is failing spectacularly in preventing drunk driving, and I think the main reason is that this over reliance of punitive measures that simply don’t work.
America is not failing to prevent drink/drunk driving. Many places allow you to drive with a bit of alcohol in your system.
It's up to the individual to be an 'adult' about their decision making/risk assessment.
No point wrapping everything in bubble wrap to keep everyone safe. Accidents happen and people selfishly go against what they should do
Is the point revenge? To make sure this doesn't happen again? Is justice = revenge? Questions...
Like I guess my point is someone who is driving drunk is already not thinking logically. You could execute drunk drivers and the rate of new drunk drivers wouldn't change.
Always amazing to me that people have more empathy for the criminals than the victims.
I have been informed of cases where drunk drivers get their licenses revoked yet continue to drive anyways. Should the system just continue to give this individual another slap on the wrist? The system should work to make the necessary adjusts to protect society from these individuals. For some, putting on a breathealyser is enough, while sometimes people start to have their friends breathe into it instead. If there is no other measure that can be taken to prevent an individual from becoming intoxicated and conducting heavy machinery, then I don't see another alternative.
> You could execute drunk drivers and the rate of new drunk drivers wouldn't change.
I'm not sure how feasible it is to make this statement because I'm not aware of anyway we could test the accuracy of this statement.
One field I'm interested in being developed is detecting cars whose drivers seem to be intoxicated with machine vision software. Some cities / countries have enough state-owned cameras in public for this, and you could combine this with IoT spikes in the road or state-controlled kill-switches to completely eradicate drunk driving.
I'd much rather see why drunk driving rates is far higher in the US than other countries with similar laws and transpiration systems.
2. Is there stuff we can do to fix the discrepancy in the US.
3. Can the perpetrator of harm in society be a part of fixing the harm they have done, and preventing more harm in society.
I think punitive justice is just the easy way out and never addresses the roots of the problems.
For example, imagine instead of jailing people for 15 years, we used that money to subsidize lyft/uber rides of 18-25 year olds when they were detected to be near bars. How much impact would that have compared to jailing?
But 15 years? Wouldn't 5 years get the point across?
Have you contemplated the insufferable loss of the two people's families? For no fault of their own, their child gets swiped away by some drunk driver who happens to be smart at math?
We have control over our decisions but not the consequences of our decisions. Punishments should fit the crime, which is fundamentally different from the result. Choosing to drive drunk is the same mistake whether it hurts no one or hurts many.
It's arguable whether it prevents others from committing similar crimes - I don't think it makes much difference if its 15 years or 30 years to make a drunk person avoid driving.
Also keep in mind, the cost-benefit of the Justice system is highly dependent on the socio-economic conditions of the city or neighborhood. Living in Geneva vs. Guadalajahara, you're going to get different answers.
What if instead of drunk driving, the accident that killed your kids involved distracted driving? Say, driver was texting? Eating a hamburger?
What if the driver was just driving 10mph over the speed limit? 15mph?
What if the driver fell asleep at the wheel?
What if the driver was driving on bald tires and a blowout precipitated the accident? What if they were only 95% worn out? 80%?
-----
There are different levels of culpability. Drunk driving is negligent and bad, but I hope we can all agree it is not as bad as willful murder. Five years in jail is an incredibly severe punishment already - that's a quarter of this kid's life to that point.
I don't buy the revenge angle. We can expect more from people.
I am so sick of seeing people who feel that justice can only be served by destroying peoples lives and making them and their families suffer to the full extent of the law. Why do we keep electing prosecutors to the high offices? Why do so many prosecutors feel they are good if they can put away the baddies for a long time? I wish we would promote and elect more defenders because they seem like the only people who see that the people facing life in prison and a family thrown into poverty are not "they" but are "we".