No way is that environmentally safe to do (imo). I’ve been on a few rigs over the years and the Topside structures are heavily contaminated with various petrochemicals.
By the time you have decontaminated it sufficiently for it not to be toxic to marine life and doing it at sea with all of the added costs and complexities vs. a full cap and off-shore decommission? Uhmm no, the sums don't add up.
Factor in the the added (admittedly pennies per tonne) value of the the scrap metal and the benefits of just leaving it there are head scratching.
Being fair – perhaps a properly capped well with the jacket left as an artificial reef might make sense, although the chances of it being snagged or snapped in the decades to come by a passing vessel probably outweighs the slight benefits of leaving it there for marine life to inhabit it.
I’m assuming that the proposal in TFA includes the costs of ensuring that all of that rusting infrastructure is properly decontaminated before it slowly corrodes and drops down to the sea bed but the article doesn't seem to mention that.
The costs of ensuring that the topside structure (the 'oil rig' bit that sticks out of the water) is properly decontaminated at sea to a level that would be safe(-ish) for marine life? Yeah, I think HN correctly spotted the smell of bs in the authors' proposal.