Just another case of "If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold".
Just another case of "If you are not paying for it, you're not the customer; you're the product being sold".
Is a user expected to tolerate illegal activity because the businesses customer demands it of them? If you have any doubt what Robinhood is doing is illegal (setting aside that it's clearly morally reprehensible), then I encourage you to read the suit that was just filed https://www.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.nysd.553175...
There's a difference between preventing someone from buying a stock and telling them you're not going to assume the risk of making a market for them, which is what's going on here. You cannot force Citadel to make a market for your orders.
They happen to result in the same situation, but the implications are completely different.
That depends on the market maker contract Citadel has with the brokerage(s) and the exchange(s). Although, I don't think the contracts with exchanges are very tight; I don't know about the contracts with brokerages. IIRC, Nasdaq had (has?) a special order type for market makers who didn't want to actually make a market that would put in bid and ask at exactly the maximum contractually allowed spread away from last trade, and withdraw and replace them when any trades did occur; making it much harder to actually trade with the market maker.
As a retail investor, I'm a little squeemish that firms want to pay me to trade with me, but given the National Best Bid and Offer requirements, I don't see what the downside is for me. It's like accepting a deal at the electronics store that's listed as 'no resellers.'
There's outrage about both. This story wouldn't be submitted and upvoted if this was common knowledge and accepted practice.
Is this a reference to margin calls?
Still not sure if this is across the board or just the larger shareholders. I'd imagine robinhood is trying to limit their risk vs. the risk of the investor.
For the smaller guys like RH though your point still stands.
I'm not defending business models built upon selling their users' data. I'm just saying that this is no surprise, and it was pretty inevitable to happen sooner or later.
Do we have any evidence Citadel is materially net short GME?
They bailed out Melvin Capital. But Melvin Capital announced that they closed out their short position. And bailing out Melvin Capital isn't the same thing as assuming their positions.
If you want to take what they say at face value, go for it, but I don't believe them.
Yeah, arm's length transactions are a means of providing truth to falsity, and perfectly crafted statements are in the same category.
The only thing missing from these press releases is "to the best of my knowledge"
Bailouts aren't arms-length transactions. They're highly involved.
Melvin Capital isn't just a GameStop short. It has billions of other assets. But not all of those are liquid. Margin calls require liquidity, and Melvin didn't have many options other than fire selling the rest of their portfolio and taking a private bailout at exorbitant terms (but less egregious than the losses they would have incurred in a fire sale).
From Citadel's perspective, why on earth would they assume the short positions? They're in the red. That is Melvin's investors' problem. The second-order problem, that of avoiding a fire sale of remaining assets, is what the bailout prevented.
With respect to Melvin, I'm blown away that these trades were executed as unhedged shorts.
Because:
> With respect to Melvin, I'm blown away that these trades were executed as unhedged shorts.
Because that ^ will take down a prime, and if it's your prime because you're buddies with your mentee... no sir. And to cap it off, dominos fall everywhere because of the Index Fund phenomenon if there's no longer 'liquidity' from these guys.
Side note: You're smart as hell, I can tell from the few times we've interacted on this forum, and I appreciate the thoughtful responses. We need to figure out a way to trade info and get a beer.
Edit: this could become a run on the banks, but instead it would be a run on equities... which is equity cost of capital worse than just withdrawing your dollars.