Source: https://www.ortex.com/symbol/nyse/gme/short_interest
It is a pyramid, but the base layer of “suckers”, those that end up taking the losses in a standard ponzi/pyramid are already determined ; they are the most finance literate people in the market, and they did it willingly. WSB is just adding layers in the middle which is rational.
The short sellers knew their risks perfectly well and did it willingly. They just didn’t expect anyone will figure out how to take advantage of the setup they created.
Whether buying stocks should be considered investment or gambling - is an entirely different distinction.
This is very likely criminal market manipulation, but I’d be surprised if it ends up with more than a slap on the wrist to anyone.
And ... at the time I wrote that, si/float was still more than 100%, so - no, they most definitely not. (Am on phone now, will check later)
The only reasonable valuation for either is (assets-liabilities), or liquidation value. All other value is based on a belief something will happen. In GameStop, it’s the belief that there are buyers of last resort who would pay almost any price - which is likely true for some of the shorts. Whether it is 1% or 10% or 100% is what these people are betting on.
And the call from industry to pause trading to regroup against Reddit indicates it’s likely a lot more than 1%