I get the point you're trying to make, but actually your example is one where I wouldn't mind. I'd rather my bad health not be the central profit driver for someone...
Aren't health insurance companies losing money by paying out? It's in their interest that their paying customers stay in good health.
alternative, it's in their interest to make paying out as difficult and byzantine as possible.
I understand it as - premiums are limited by law as a multiple of payouts. The more they pay out, the higher premiums they can charge. So, peversly, the more they pay out, the more they can make.
Health insurance companies are allowed to make a certain percentage of profit, so they actually don't have a strong incentive to keep payouts down.