I'm not a fan of the traditional credit reporting system. It is often a black box that makes it difficult to understand how the actual credit scoring algorithm works. Although one of the important aspects of the current system is that all the inputs are known. We don't know exactly to what degree each input matters, but we know the inputs. A new system needs to keep that aspect or else is going to cause pain for a lot of people who are financially punished without being aware of why. This type of transparency is also important for fairness. As other commenters have mentioned, some traits like race would be a good indicator of credit worthiness due to a variety of systemic socioeconomic issues. However that is generally considered unfair and is illegal to take that into consideration.