... Nothing in this article seems specific to ERCOT's grid vs any random ISO seeing a demand/supply mismatch.
... Nothing in this article seems specific to ERCOT's grid vs any random ISO seeing a demand/supply mismatch.
>“The operators who took those actions to prevent a catastrophic blackout and much worse damage to our system, that was, I would say, the most difficult decision that had to be made throughout this whole event," Magness said.
>"At the end of the day, our operators are highly trained and have the authority to make decisions that protect the reliability of the electric system,"
strongly implies ERCOT had absolutely no working plan to deal with this issue and instead relied on observance and skill of operators to save them from complete and total blackout.
CAISO is an example of how this should work. it has detailed and thorough plans for high winds, inclement weather, earthquake, fires tsunami and flood. If there is an ISO flex alert for customers to save energy or a blackout is planned, its generally forecast with days to spare. Operators and plants are shut down and restarted in a coordinated, orderly fashion with excellent communication and transparency. CAISO even takes into account climate change and will mail out free coupons for bagged ice for users in a shut-down area along with maps to cooling centers or warming centers if need be. http://www.caiso.com/
Another way of looking at it is that they implemented phase 3 of this plan:
http://www.ercot.com/content/wcm/current_guides/53525/04-030...
"absolutely no working plan" would look different.... which is the point of the article.
> to deal with this issue and instead relied on observance and skill of operators to save them from complete and total blackout.
Sometimes the operators have to intervene to keep things running. In in big moments like this, and many, many, many smaller moments you never even notice.
"Highly trained and well equipped fire fighters save neighborhood from burning down"
Not so, here. There was no need to be this close to the cliff.
I do not know the answer to this question. I know nothing about power grids. However, if they were following such a strategy, it's not surprising that they would end up disabling the system "seconds and minutes away from a catastrophic failure". That does not make the shutdown a last-minute precarious decision. It could be a preplanned response to a certain combination of failure conditions.
The article fails to disambiguate between "react quickly with a planned decision" and "react quickly after analyzing the whole situation from scratch". The latter makes the operator seem more heroic.
I agree with nimbius that some of the quotes lean towards the latter, but it would be better if the article removed the ambiguity.
What enforcement mechanisms do the grid operators have?
I’m under NDA so I can’t go into detail. I can say everybody at the ISO’s are just trying to hang on. The do a fantastic job. They don’t control spending on grid infra.
In other girds electricity costs little more and produced are required to maintain excess capacity and prepare for larger fluctuations in demand and weather. It costs little more, but is more reliable.
No, as Democrats want that.
https://cbsaustin.com/news/local/rick-perry-says-texans-woul...
Perry, who also served as the Secretary of Energy in the Trump administration, made the comment in an interview with Republican House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy.
Looks like Perry is (R) since 1989 and (D) before that https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rick_Perry .