https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Smallpox#Eradication
Obviously every disease is different, but since it's only been done twice EVER, I would learn toward the burden of proof being on those to explain why it's realistic, not for those to explain why it's UNrealistic.
I would summarize it as "The world is very big and there are a lot of people and places that got infected" ...
there are, or there might be? Is there any evidence that COVID-19 exists in an animal population in any significant density? And, if so, couldn't that population just be quickly culled?
Many different viruses (far more deadly than COVID-19) are known to exist in bats and guano, but they rarely escape into the larger human population. Not to say never, but the cross-over is rare and seems to be reducible with increased education.
Here's a good article on viral escape: https://www.washingtonpost.com/nation/interactive/2021/vacci...