I see these kind of strange examples posted. Like you posted, and others usually involve travel stories where the person was supposedly in the region and "didn't see anything".
The general idea here is that the oppression has reached the level of genocide... with that in mind:
Are people supposed to find an oppressed people showing up on video convincing of anything? Is the opposite even possible from inside China?
Does anyone find hostage videos convincing?
Is "laughing at the absurdity of it" supposed to convince people of something?
Look, no one can convince someone of something when they are hellbent on seeing things in a certain light. I’m sure if you look hard enough, you can find some Uyghur somewhere in those videos blinking out “HELP ME” in morse.
But if Westerners are hyperventilating over Uyghur genocide while thousands of actual Uyghurs living in Xinjiang are making videos laughing at the allegations, don’t you think there’s something wrong with that picture? Rhetorical question.
Here’s another great channel from an Uyghur Vlogger showing everyday life in Xinjiang (she posts on Bilibili but her fans have been reposting to Youtube). Nothing about that screams genocide to me, sorry.
This is what I don't get. Such reliance on one off social media examples.
If I found a video that said otherwise ... would that convince you? Why would you think it works the other way?
Such reliance on such heavily anecdotal things (on some social media posts) seems very ... simple / a strange way to choose what to believe or even convince people.
When an actual genocide happens, you see massive flows of refugees trying to escape. Where are the news of massive flows of Chinese refugees in Kazakhstan, Russia, Kyrgyzstan?
You’re acting like it’s my goal or duty to convince you, which is not the case. You can choose to believe what you want to believe.
My simple goal here today is to make the point that the US has a long track record of manufacturing consent to achieve its geopolitical goals and that we all should be aware and on guard for it. This Uyghur genocide story throws up too many red flags for me.
Here’s Lawrence Wilkerson (retired United States Army Colonel and former chief of staff to United States Secretary of State Colin Powell) being very candid about America’s interest in Xinjiang. Hint: it’s not because they care about Uyghurs.
>It’s no different than how the entire Western media establishment has been relying on one-off style testimonies pushing atrocity propaganda and basing almost their entire genocide thesis off of anecdotal evidence.
I think you greatly misunderstand how western media operates.
But that's not really surprising. I find folks who sympathize with non free states often misunderstand that their government's propaganda is not equal to how western media operates. It's just not a 1:1.
> I think you greatly misunderstand how western media operates.
I definitely used to greatly misunderstand how Western media operates. I was naive to the extent that I believed the invasion of Iraq was necessary. Now I’m under no such illusions.
To start, Gray Zone founder Max Blumenthal attended the same expenses-paid 2015 gala in Russia, celebrating RT's 10-year anniversary, at which Jill Stein and Mike Flynn were photographed sitting with Vladimir Putin. Like Flynn, Blumenthal was paid to be there:
https://www.motherjones.com/politics/2017/05/flynn-putin-din...
One month after the gala, Blumenthal founded The Gray Zone. At this time he did a 180 from his earlier anti-Assad reporting to become one of that dictator's biggest supporters:
https://www.commentarymagazine.com/articles/bruce-bawer/usef...
The Gray Zone also publishes pro-dictator reports on Venezuela, another ally of the Russian government. Here's a 2019 video of Blumenthal personally & cheerfully receiving honors from Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro, who has ruled that country by violence and decree since 2015:
https://twitter.com/NicolasMaduro/status/1156588153945427970
Here's a piece that goes into detail on shortcomings in The Gray Zone's Venezuela reporting. Blumenthal and his employees have denied the existence of that country's ongoing humanitarian crisis, in which 20% of the Venezuelan population has fled the country as economic refugees:
https://medium.com/muros-invisibles/grayzone-grifters-and-th...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Venezuelan_refugee_crisis
Not all of The Gray Zone's reporting is flawed, but there's enough to make me seriously question their aims and journalistic integrity. Their source of funding remains obscure. They don't run ads, don't sell subscriptions, and their Patreon is tiny, yet they're flying people all over the world. Blumenthal is also now a frequent Sputnik and RT contributor. It's my suspicion that they're a propaganda outlet aimed at Western skeptics, the anti-war crowd, and intellectuals.