For 1, I guess we need to know what % of consumers use credit cards/would prefer to use credit cards vs. cash only. With 600m CCs in circulation in the US, I do not think it's fair to say that customers who pay with credit/debit cards is a minority. For 2, like I said, by moving the sign inside, he may get a customer once who pays with cash, but who knows if they will return to pay with cash a second time knowing that they don't accept a CC? 3rd, the donut being a loss leader is a well taken point - depends what his target market is though. My point in raising these concerns is just that we shouldn't look at these lessons blindly, they need real economic analysis and probably some financial data to understand how well they are working vs. other options the owner could have taken.