Like a Peloton is really good, yeah, but there's probably a $1000 treadmill that's pretty good, or Traeger makes great if overpriced pellet grills, but there's definitely some cheaper options that will smoke your meat fine if you don't need wifi and bluetooth for your smoker. And then sometimes the expensive products are really terrible quality with an aura of mystique about then (looking at you, Molekule air purifier) and Consumer Reports is willing to call these snake oil salesmen companies.
I don't trust any other reviews, though.
I used to subscribe, my sense is that they do a good job, but their tastes are geared toward those of more affluent boomers and genxers. If you're someone who can't afford a Lexus, or who'd even consider choosing a Kia over a Lexus even though you can easily afford one, then Consumer Reports may not cater to your tastes.
They do surveys of consumers as well as do their own testing. About once a year they survey about vacuum cleaners - I had to buy one recently, and some brands got high grades, other low grades - so I bought a Shark vacuum cleaner. A few years ago I needed to buy an air conditioner and used CR for that as well. I also needed a laptop in a hurry and CR was one source I consulted (although I consulted several sources).
$40 a year is worth it to me to get a decent air conditioner and vacuum cleaner and such at a decent price (and laptop, although CR was just once of the consulted sources). The Shark vacuum cleaner was the last item I bought and it picks up dirt good, is easy to empty, and can vacuum rugs as well as things that need the hose to vacuum.
That would have been the mid-late 80s, but it set the tone for the time: rate something high because it was cheap not because it was the best for the job.