Most likely so. But that $25 or so per year is most likely not going to Apple but being split by the record labels. Others have pointed out this is kind of a piracy amnesty. The average person just isn't going to go nuts pirating music to get some sort of deal. Those aren't the kind of people buying iDevices. Besides which, don't people have to upload the music for the scan? Broadband uploads speeds are crap, again whittling away whatever incentive people might have to load up on stolen music.