i can’t put my finger on it
but feels like a strong bout of collective insanity
high on ideas
abusing language and metaphor and analogy to the point we no longer understand what is real and unreal
i can’t put my finger on it
but feels like a strong bout of collective insanity
high on ideas
abusing language and metaphor and analogy to the point we no longer understand what is real and unreal
NFTs are the new shitcoins, without even a pretense of being generally useful. Digital Beanie Babies will surely be worth something long term, but nowhere near the bubble we're about to see.
Then again, Bitcoin itself is the original non-fungible token, lacking the critical ecash proprietary of untraceability. So what do I know.
It may give you some theoretical infinitesimal ownership of the company.
But since Alphabet doesn't pay dividends, there is zero cash flow.
And it doesn't even give you the right to vote.
There's no scenario where you can convert your share into physical assets of the company, or claim any portion of the future cash flows of the company.
And unlike NFTs, a share of GOOG isn't even rare. There are 330 million others identical to yours.
A share of GOOG is just an entry in an electronic ledger, and literally the only thing you can do with it is sell it to someone else.
And yet people happily pay $2,100 for one, with no other objective than to resell it to someone else for more.
In such markets, pieces are status, which has nothing really to do with matter (in a physical sense). Specifically:
- status is sold; Jack Dorsey is famous, and his first tweet is strongly symbolic;
- status is acquired/purchased; the buyer has the money for the purchase, and he'll fits the item likely in a sort of private collection.
The status interpretation can make more intuitive the nature of the transaction/item, dispelling the insanity interpretation.
It needs to be considered also that this can be very conventional speculation; in this sense, it would appear intuitively "not insane", like financial instruments (of course, in another sense, they are fundamentally insane :)).
¹=https://www.amazon.com/Million-Stuffed-Shark-Economics-Conte...
Maybe he's doing a proof-of-concept for something else Twitter is developing (almost infinitely more likely than Jack doing money laundering), but this stuff just seems weird for rich tech people to do. This is like certificates of authenticity for random infomercial products, just on the blockchain.
https://newrepublic.com/article/147192/modern-art-serves-ric...
What's more useless:
a) $2.5m sitting in a bank account, vulnerable to taxation, confiscation, legal judgment, gradual inflation, rapid devaluation and bank insolvency, unlikely to increase much in value, where the only thing you can do with it is trade it for something useful.
b) $2.5m invested in something rare, that could increase in value, where you can both trade it for something else you want, or appreciate the object itself and enjoy owning it.
> What's more useless:
> a) $2.5m sitting in a bank account, vulnerable to taxation, confiscation, legal judgment, gradual inflation, rapid devaluation and bank insolvency, unlikely to increase much in value, where the only thing you can do with it is trade it for something useful.
> b) $2.5m invested in something rare, that could increase in value, where you can both trade it for something else you want, or appreciate the object itself and enjoy owning it.
Holding an NFT should be benchmarked against holding BTC. The way you've presented it — as being either USD or NFT — is clearly a false dichotomy.
Something rare is just that, something rare. It produces nothing.
And neither is fractional reserve banking.
Yeah, it is.
To put it simply to the point of absurdity, if we were a "magical" (in Arthur C. Clarke's word) civilization without any outstanding needs, we could still play some for-profit economic game and spend quadrillions buying autographs, because it wouldn't lessen anything of importance. Conversely, if you're barely eating enough, you won't spend resources on anything else than getting more food, because that would lessen your chances of survival.
The degree of perceived insanity, I think, thus entirely depends on who you are as a beholder of value, where you fit in the material ⇾ idealistic spectrum. Pretty sure Africans with $1/day feel this is perfectly stupid, but your average billionaire might find it a funny hobby, like collecting some cards of the digital era. There will be a market for that, I think crypto-manias proved as much.
It's all relative to an observer, IMHO.
Still, at least with physical things, we know there is limited quantity of quality. Same can't be said about digital products...