A knighthood is a seriously different beast to a PhD e.g. Paul Graham will never be shown off alone to an audience of billions in an olympic opening ceremony.
The fact that the queen or similar taps you on the shoulders is an implementation detail
If you want to be petty all you have to do to get a PhD is pass a viva - Two slightly bizarre french "physicists" come to mind
This gets lost in translation. I (in the US) tend to see it more like GP does as well.