to this day, im not sure how i feel about this topic. I saw the US Navy undergo a lot of changes in this regard while i was serving. historically, various forms of hazing and abuse have been a part of the culture and advancement process. this has fallen out of favor and policy has either eliminated or taken the teeth out of these older practices.
im not convinced it has been a net positive. there are certainly some positives, but there are also some negatives. having abuse in the pipeline means that the only people that make it through are strong enough to withstand abuse and this strength is a positive quality. however, good people that might otherwise have performed well are sometimes lost.
ive known people that have had psychotic breaks or jumped off the ship in the middle of the ocean, but i also knew concentrated forces of willpower, warfighting engineers that inspire me to this day. would more or less hazing have changed either one of those groups?