I think if you're following the literature, there's a significant amount that's pointing to the above generalization capabilities that you're contending against because it may not seem likely from your personal experience.
If you were to look at your arguments, I think you're extending the idea of expert systems from the 90's and so on and using that to paint a picture of the entire research field of deep learning process today. What we have has the capabilities to not be bound by those things, just the long bootstrapping process takes time. But we're getting closer year by year, and it's more and more exciting along that front as time goes along.
As for experience, I am and have been a practicioner in this field for several years.