When you register for notifications it sends out a verification email. That would be a good time to let you disable public lookup of your email address.
I also wish HIBP could securely disclose the snippet of information from a leak that's relevant to you. Knowing the password or hash characteristics, phone number, etc. could aid in mitigation, and seeing the raw impact might help motivate ordinary users to improve their security hygiene.
Suggested that idea to Troy in the past, and got the impression he's not amenable, largely due to the risks of hosting PII. Can't really blame him.