Don't tell me anyone involved in doing this felt like this was 'the right way to go'. Which makes exact motivation behind it all the more questionable.
Don't tell me anyone involved in doing this felt like this was 'the right way to go'. Which makes exact motivation behind it all the more questionable.
If this feature is to stay relevant, it has to be integrated within Signal. Otherwise competitors (who do integrate a payment feature) will just have a better UX.
The choice was basically:
1. have the feature within Signal
2. have no user
They chose 1.
I think we need a reality check here. When I check the Playstore, Signal has 50M downloads. WhatsApp has 2B. Signal is still largely the underdog.
I could definitely imagine a few people using a "Signal Payments" app instead of whatever WA offers. But to actually compete with WhatsApp (which won't create a separate app), you can't afford to split the app in two. The aim is not that HN users are able to transfer money in a privacy-preserving way, it's that everybody can.
Signal's (meaning the app) goal should be to be a long-term, secure, honest alternative for more privacy minded users, no matter their technical expertise? At least that's what I'm thinking.
I see it more like setting the baseline for the whole ecosystem. If Signal allows me to do X privately, why can't WhatsApp? To have this clout, they need to keep a non negligible market share and remain a threat to other messengers, which you can't do if you miss features your competitors have and that users value.