Well that's actully what U+008B (PLD, Partial Line Down) and U+008C (PLU, Partial Line Up (though officially it's inexplicably Partial Line Backward)) were originally for:
PLD text PLU would produce a subscript and PLU text PLD would produce a superscript.
Superscripts are a typesetting concern, not an encoding concern.
No they鈥檙e not. Superscripts and subscripts in English as used in literature may be a typesetting concern but that鈥檚 not their only purpose. Eg in chemical notations or in mathematical text it is not a matter of typesetting but an actual separate symbol with distinct semantics.
If they change the semantic meaning of the text is that not under Unicode's purview?
Italics change the semantic meaning of text too, but they're still rich text, not plaintext. Unicode has been generally taken the attitude that Unicode is for plaintext, not rich text, even if it's stretched the meaning of that a bit. (There's also the time they goofed up and added interlinear annotation, which is pretty clearly not plaintext, but they've since discouraged the use of that and I don't think they want to make any more mistakes like that.)
Unicode 饾槬饾槹饾槮饾槾 have italic characters (at least for A-Z a-z) although they are labeled as math characters.
Sure, I could have chosen a more watertight example to demonstrate the point. (And I think that "although" is an important "although" -- those characters are not meant to be used for ordinary italics; if you do this, you're going to cause significant problems for anyone trying to process your text, such as by, say, searching it.) It doesn't have, I don't know, characters that are blue-colored bold italic underlined superscripts, you know? Whatever exceptions or seeming-exceptions Unicode may have made, they're not looking to make more of them.
For sure. I think you are right. I'm just pointing out that the line here is much blurrier than Unicode probably wishes it was.