We (in the West) are big on theater: we've closed public parks, we wear masks outside, and we loooove sanitizing surfaces. Those things are expensive, distracting, and totally ineffective.
South Korea and Vietnam don't have super strict lockdowns or quarantines. Instead, they wear masks indoors and have effective contact tracing.
FYI, reverse contact tracing is even more effective, because most people aren't highly contagious, which means new cases likely came from a relatively rare super-contagious case. Step backwards to find that person, then contact trace them. Like fire against a grass-type, it's super effective.
> reverse contact tracing is even more effective
Yes, but in some cultures that type of measures is seen as running against the idea of "freedom", however they choose to define it. This is the root cause. It's a cultural thing, a set of shared ideas.
Turns out, when you're dealing with a nanoscale replicator that only operates on statistics, individuals and their "freedom" are irrelevant. What really matters is how the collective strategy is shaped.
Florida and Texas did not have extended lockdowns, and their numbers are not worse that the states that did, and in many cases better. Also, Texas cases went down 3 weeks after mask mandate was lifted. Watch Bill Maher - New Rules from last Friday.
As for Texas and Florida, I'd love to see some more details on how you're comparing them to other states. It seems like there are a lot of variables you would need to control for (population age and lifestyle, existing healthcare infrastructure, voluntary compliance with guidelines exclusive of legal requirement, etc.). But suffice to say, Florida is in pretty bad shape right now relative to the rest of the U.S., so I'm not sure it makes a good example for your argument.
My area had effective mayors who enforced policies, checked businesses, and spent a lot of energy in keeping people safer, and we did much better than many parts of the state where no one cared. Mask use everywhere I go is high which I think is the biggest measure of what works. There are parts of Florida where no one wears a mask or cares to do anything. I always wanted to see per capita cases/deaths per zip code or even voting district, but no one does that.
There's strict and then there's strict:
> “This comparison isn’t an accident. [COVID deniers] are stacking the deck by choosing outliers that favor their argument,” she said.
> The data bears this out.
> North Dakota and South Dakota are both among the least restrictive states in the country with the higher per capita case rates of COVID-19 in the country.
> North Dakota has had 13,036 cases per 100,000 residents while South Dakota has had 12,585 per 100,000, according to data tracking from the New York Times.
> Vermont and Hawaii, on the other hand, have some of the lowest per capita case rates in the country (2,341 and 1,912 per 100,000, respectively) and among the most restrictive policies, according to data analysis from WalletHub.
> This doesn’t necessarily prove that more restrictions are better than fewer, either — and that’s just the point.
[…]
> “Even the very restrictive states weren’t all that restrictive when you compare to places like Spain, Italy, Australia, New Zealand,” Robinson said. “Without good quarantines, income supports, worker rights, a lot of what was done in a state like California was nibbling around the edges — closed schools and churches but open restaurants and bars.”
* https://www.healthline.com/health-news/why-do-california-and...
Los Angeles - 234.6 deaths per 100k residents
San Francisco - 46.3 deaths per 100k residents
Austin - 178.7 deaths per 100k residents
San Antonio - 81.5 deaths per 100k residents
The West needs to take a long look at itself in the mirror, seeing as some of its fundamental ideas are inadequate when dealing with a blind, pure-numbers threat that only cares about statistics.
I'm not saying some of the collectivist excesses seen in some parts of the "East" are okay, but the other extreme turns out to be maladaptive, too.
My gut feeling is that it can be traced back to Ayn Rand & Co, but it's hard to say. But around that time, and near that environment, some spectacularly evil things came to be accepted as "reasonable".
Like someone who almost drowned in the ocean, and then thinks showers are evil.
I think it's more about how well people follow restrictions than how strict the policy is.
Even when authorities get some responses wrong, but people follow them, it helps because you can correct them. If you have cynical attitude, that government was wrong on this detail, so everything is now bullshit, nothing will work.
I keep hearing this but is there any hard data or studies to back it up? The numbers I've seen comparing e.g. Google Mobility data to case transmission rates haven't shown much correlation at all, let alone causation.
Then, the British variant arrived and here we are, world champions in deaths per thousand people.
There's still no Armageddon happening anywhere.
https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/70/wr/mm7010e3.htm#F1_down
It's "percentage point change," which I read as absolute percentage points. It's different from you what said, "masks reduce transmission by all of 2%," but it also looks like a garbage number because you can't average percents like that and get meaningful data, and the result is hard to interpret. If masks drop the growth rate by 2 percentage point, two percentage points from what?
Well, with effective measures to control the virus. Places like Taiwan never really locked down - that's more an emergency measure to use after things have run out of control.