I only go to Allrecipes now for exactly this reason. It’s funny, people used to mock that site for the stupid reviews, but what matters can quickly change...
I found Josh Weissman to have good recipes. You could also look for recipes by experienced chefs like by Munchies.
Also if you have more experience. You can look at a recipe and easily figure out if something is very wrong. Unfortunately, most things on cooking don't tell you how to "debug" recipes. You just cook often and hope you can figure things out.