Why not have both? This whole topic would be a non-issue if we still had Touch ID as an option.
If you support just one with the other disabled, it is wasted hardware/space in a device with extremely limited size/cost budget. If you require both, you haven't fixed the usability issues.
The touchID on my new MacBook Pro is extremely useful. Trained on right index finger.
Also, these are not “extreme” or “dire” or even uncommon conditions - most of Northern Europe, Canada, and the north-eastern USA experience several months of such conditions every year.