That's not how Islam works. That's how it was able to survive against the torrent of corruption that affected Christianity and Judaism. The Quran and Hadiths are preserved so that we're easily able to consult them to determine who is and isn't a Muslim. Note that this isn't gate keeping, Islam is wide open for anyone to accept. However, the tenants are strict enough to survive the passage of time.
> You can call them a bad Muslim, ignorant, misinformed, misguided etc. But they are what they believe themselves to be.
This already happens. I'm talking about the extremes that the secular West has adopted, whereby people can inherit their parents religion, even if they don't believe in it.