I recall seeing report of a similar result many years ago (at least 10, perhaps much more) where VAWTs deployed in complementary pairs were shown to be more efficient, so this looks like a repeat /rediscovery of the same result.
I recall seeing report of a similar result many years ago (at least 10, perhaps much more) where VAWTs deployed in complementary pairs were shown to be more efficient, so this looks like a repeat /rediscovery of the same result.
Basically, noise would indicate either some problem with loose parts, a lot of friction, turbulence or something else that is clearly being inefficient. Obviously to compete with state of the art horizontal turbines, you'd use highly durable materials with awesomely low friction and generally be shooting for very high levels of efficiency.
Some other things I've seen suggests that small vertical turbines are suitable for deployment in urban environments where they work with low/variable wind speeds at completely acceptable noise levels. You could put these on your roof even. I left a link elsewhere in this thread if you are interested.
Basically the article is about a group of scientists that ran the numbers and came up with different conclusions than you. 15% more efficient is quite a lot.
It'd be easier to sort out with all of the videos uploaded to YouTube if humans were capable of not adding cheesy soundtracks to everything.
This brings up another interesting point. If there are concerns around ship engines and submarine sonar or ELF for marine life, I wonder if any testing has been done concerning that with the turbines.
"The noise emission from the wind turbine was measured, at wind speed 8 m/s, 10 m above ground, to 96.2 dBA"
https://www.mdpi.com/1996-1073/9/1/19/htm
[Edited to add: What I wrote about hydro black start units was really wrong, I wasn't thinking when I wrote that, it needs far more detailed explanation like the comment below.]
This is a misunderstanding. All generators require an excitation current to start up. Most generators get this excitation from the grid. For large, important generators they also have black start, so that they can provide excitation on-site. This means they don't need to bootstrap themselves from a grid.
Hydro tends to have black start not because 'they need it' but because it is critically important from a grid security perspective. During a blackout, you want your high inertia, flexible machines online first - these are hydros for systems that have them. If you don't have blackstart on these machines, you need them on some other machine online first to energize the grid.
You wouldn't put blackstart units on wind turbines, simply because they are worthless if there isn't already an energised grid to support into (they aren't grid forming). So you can always assume grid-based excitation current for wind generators.
I think OP was talking about the cut-in speed (at what wind speed can the turbine start producing power). For HAWTs this is at wind speeds of around 5 m/s. For VAWTs, I don't know, but I assume it is a little higher based on the OP's comment, and that they may even need some mechanical assistance to get them spinning in the first place.
“The noise emission at 6 m/s 10 m above ground was measured to 94.1 dBA, this while while operating at optimum tip speed. Available noise surveys performed on similar sized operating at optimum tip speed. Available noise surveys performed on similar sized HAWTs [27–30] HAWTs [27–30] has established noise emissions of 95.1–100.2 dBA and 97.3–102.4 dBA for 6 m/s and has established noise emissions of 95.1–100.2 dBA and 97.3–102.4 dBA for 6 m/s and 8 m/s respectively”