>These payments are recouped from the income taxes Apple’s new employees would normally pay to the state.
Are they not paying the money to the state?
If there's anyone who /doesn't/ need a competitive advantage, it's Apple. They are utterly smashing their competition in every regard already.
Property taxes will go to fund schools and state governments, not to mention localized sales tax and cash infusion.
In fact, I would consider high property taxes with zero income tax to be a rather regressive form of taxation that strongly benefits high income earners.
It's not about income tax so much as it is about the government subsidy being granted and whether or not it's the best use of the government's limited financial resources.
Now do California. Clearly high taxation doesn't correlate to stable electrical power.
There's a handful of states without income taxes. They mostly manage just fine. Or about as fine as the states with income taxes. They raise similar revenues in other ways.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000%E2%80%9301_California_ele...
All I could find was this, the wikipedia article doesn't mention any deaths however, whereas it appears 70 people died during the Texas crisis this year. I'm aware of the rolling blackouts in the bay area least year as my employer was impacted but it seemed more or less livable due to their rolling nature.
I live in a state without income tax. Its actually quite a shit show: https://www.bizjournals.com/seattle/news/2020/10/22/mark-har...
And poor areas become poorer because the local municipality collects less taxes than the one with more affluent residents.
Ultra-locality of spending isn't efficient, it just maintains the status quo, it makes counties compete between each other for companies or residents and not all can attract the rich people or companies to fund themselves.
Schools should be equally funded regardless of how rich the people who live in the area are. This is the most basic component for an equitable society: a level playing field on education.
That's debatable. Just because they do it doesn't mean it's a good idea.