What trees are you talking about ? or you mean in general ?
What trees are you talking about ? or you mean in general ?
In particular, many trees grow from a central strem that is nearly perfectly vertical, and many have a more organic growth pattern. I see no reason to assume these have common ancestors that were trees any more than crabs and jellyfish.
Some examples where your description doesn’t hold up so well
- palm trees
- bamboo
- fringe tree (Chionanthus virginicus)
- Hydrangea paniculata
- sunflowers
- crape myrtles can have so many variations that it’s crazy
It's not very much like e.g. an oak tree. More like a scaled-up celery.
It is pretty obviously an enormous grass. Woody? Yes. Tree? No.
Woody hollow stems which don't grow rings, are canes. If less woody and more herbaceous, it's a reed.
The "tiebreaker" if you will, is palm wood. No rings, but it's dense, not hollow, it has a grain and it's lignin-rich. You can make planks with it. It's a weird wood, but it's wood. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coconut_timber
Ultimately "wood" is just a word, people will use it however they do.
Canes take the adjective "woody" but not the noun "wood". Bamboo can make some interesting laminate materials, but these are not normally referred to as wood either, although they are lumber.
I've done a fair amount of woodworking, but I don't think I've ever worked with bamboo. But if I were to, I'd be a lot more attuned to the distinction.
Palm trees do "grow from a central stem that is nearly perfectly vertical", and are woody, and conventionally are considered trees. Bamboo matches both of those criteria, in fact, but it has a "just look at it" grassness to it. Growing in clusters from rhizomes is pretty un-tree-like, but no one of these things is diagnostic.
What is and isn't a tree is more cultural than biological, which is, I believe, the original author's point.