Being against free trade works for an economy right up until it has fully squandered its competitive advantage (derived in great part in the modern world by leveraging comparative advantage) and then GDP and the tax base start collapsing. And then capital flight happens when the combination of protectionism and necessarily increased taxes to sustain government programs makes it prohibitive to conduct business, compounding the vicious contractive cycle.
Retarding an economy with protectionist policies is a losing strategy in the long term. The only way to win is education and retraining. That's it.
We did just like China starting out, rather than be stuck undeveloped, enslaved to comparative advantage, we stole trade secrets from the more powerful nation, heavily subsidized R&D, and education (as you point out as a good thing), etc. See for instance "Slater the Traitor" as the British knew him:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Samuel_Slater
If the WTO existed back then we might have gotten invaded and blockaded over it.
All the Asian tiger countries avoided almost all of our free trade advice and did heavily protectionist policies in order to achieve their rapid development. Most of the countries that bought into it remained third world, pursuing their comparative advantage as an undeveloped nation against developed ones, which seems to basically be shorthand for having their natural resources looted.
The book Bad Samaritans goes into how that development occurred in S. Korea, and other similar countries that successfully broke out of the comparative advantage trap:
Why are you holding government R&D as mutually exclusive of free trade policy and an open economy?
> we'd be just trading in furs and stuff.
Asinine straw man.
> rather than be stuck undeveloped, enslaved to comparative advantage, we stole trade secrets from the more powerful nation, heavily subsidized R&D
Either/or fallacy once again.
> All the Asian tiger countries avoided almost all of our free trade advice and did heavily protectionist policies in order to achieve their rapid development.
This statement is laughably false. Hong Kong, Singapore, South Korea, and Taiwan are practically famous for having leveraged free trade and open economies to catapult to economic stardom.
On the whole, this is a stunningly poor counterargument. It's so lacking in sense that it reads like it was generated by GPT-3.
The state played a heavy role in all of them:
"The four countries were inspired by Japan's evident success, and they collectively pursued the same goal by investing in the same categories: infrastructure and education."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Asian_Tigers
Re: protectionism and South Korea I think Ha-Joon Chang covered the development of their steel industry (a later big force behind their "free trade" auto industry) for an example of extreme protectionism in the book I linked. Samsung is practically corporate-state.
Once capabilities are developed and become a comparative advantage for a state, they encourage free trade in them and attack others' subsidies as being protectionist by benefiting the upstart state's local industry instead of pursuing comparative advantage in menial labor, natural resources, etc. (Chang's book Kicking Away the Ladder is about this I think).
I've noticed that for the most part every time a corporation export jobs it's the corporation's fault. Whenever a corporation brings jobs to the US the politicians get credit for good policy.
From the cultural left, if you believe that nationalism is immoral and everyone is a global citizen with nation-states being obsolete and even illegetimate ideas, you can't expect someone to have a sense of loyalty to his fellow citizens and not outsource. After all, why deny good jobs to the poor in other countries who benefit from them? Isn't it bigoted for a company to want to keep jobs in America? So that's why the left is strangely silent on these trade deficits, and attacks anyone who raises concerns about them as "nativist".
On the economic right, if you believe that profit maximizing behavior leads to pareto-maximizing outcomes, why would you interfere with a company that decides to boost profits by outsourcing?
It is the cultural right, economic left that remains shaking their heads at what are obviously foolish, self-destructive policies, but they are generally locked out of power in this country, and so the national firesale continues.