We really need to stop mixing up our stock and flows, and putting dollar amounts derived from the latter to the former in ways that make no sense.
We really need to stop mixing up our stock and flows, and putting dollar amounts derived from the latter to the former in ways that make no sense.
The circumstances are quite surprising given that this was his family office. From previous stories it sounded like Archegos was a hedge fund that blew up and lost investor money - but reading this it seems he was gambling with swaps on his own money plus whatever investment banks would lend him.
It kind of sounds like he screwed up in losing his fortune, but rather than any kind of fraud the banks in question just screwed up worse by not doing proper diligence on their borrower (although obviously we don’t have insight into what was disclosed to the lenders, so who knows?).
“If you owe the bank a thousand bucks you have a problem, if you owe the bank a million bucks they have a problem” comes to mind.
He used CFDs which are a type of OTC derivative. Instead of buying the stock, you put up some margin and (usually) promise to swap cash daily based on the movement in an underlying stock (or basket of stocks) i.e. instead of buying F, you promise to pay/receive the loss/gain in F stock every day.
The leverage comes, of course, when investment banks say you can pay/receive the cash flows on a position worth X shares but only need to put margin that is significantly less than the actual purchase price for X shares i.e. for a $100 notional exposure, you only need to put up $5 in margin.
Something to bear in mind if this sounds confusing. The risk doesn't go anywhere. If an investment bank agrees to pay the gain in the share price of AMZN, they hedge their risk by buying shares. There are a few unique things about the case, it seems implausible that Archegos weren't aware they were cornering the market for certain stocks through investment banks hedging their exposure, but the macro point is that the risk hasn't disappeared.
Amazingly, this happened in 2007 too (everyone thought that the MBS market was deep and liquid...no, it was pretty much all owned by some particularly dense bankers in Germany/Japan/etc.). People forget that risk doesn't go anywhere and there is a point where risk-taking is just too high relative to the actual productivity of the underlying assets.
Also, I don't the detail is out there. But the $20bn, I believe, refers to the gross leveraged position. It is very likely that he was leveraging every bit of equity he had on the way up (it doesn't matter anyway, all of his equity is going to be wiped out).
Actually, now that I think of it, it's even worse that that! - its taking other people's money, then leveraging it, and then charging 2-and-20.
Who needs to be a criminal when you can just do this instead?
No one really weeps for this guy. This is absolutely a situation where you can be Nelson (from the Simpsons) and just laugh at this idiot's mistake, without feeling bad about it. Overleveraging billions of your own money, and losing it all in a couple of days takes a certain level of recklessness.
There were a few banks that got caught up in this issue (Credit Suisse lost $5 billion on this). But once again, we can just sit back and laugh at Credit Suisse for failing to account for the risk in granting Bill Hwang leverage.
Not like an "Evil Laugh" or anything, but... sometimes investors make a mistake (be it a fund like Archegos Capital, or a bank like Credit Suisse). When they make mistakes, they loose $Billions. That's part of the risks they take when they do their business. Fair game when they lose on their bets.
There's no guarantee that any of this crap makes money. Investors make the decision that they're willing to risk money for the opportunity to make more money later. That's fundamental to the stock market (and bond market).
When schemes like archegos blow up, it often costs a lot of people who don’t even know they have invested in stocks (e.g their pension fund does) some of their life savings.
Archegos isn't a "scheme". Its a private hedge fund for Bill Hwang's family.
I mean, it really sucks for him and his family to lose $20,000,000,000 in a couple of days. But... this dude was playing with fire.
And yeah, sucks for Credit Susie who was left "holding the bag" on Archegos's margin calls (all other banks liquidated ahead of time and got out safely. Credit Susie was slow on the uptake and was left with a $5 Billion bill).
But guess what? Lending $Billions to reckless billionaires sometimes causes your bank to lose money. That's well within the risk-reward calculus. And a "big wall street bank" losing single-digit $Billions on a bet happens at least a few times each year: its not even that rare of an incident. This is literally the business they're in. (Indeed: banks like Credit Susie lend money somewhat recklessly because they know they can afford the loss if the bet goes sideways. I doubt anyone at Credit Susie is going to even get fired over this incident, its really not that big a deal.)
Honestly, this implosion is great entertainment because everything happened correctly. The damage is almost entirely isolated to Bill Hwang and his closest associates (family members, and some unfortunate church-members who got roped in). But it seems like Bill Hwang was a relatively honest fellow: so he didn't really screw anyone else over aside from himself.
Pretty much everyone in this story got "what they deserved". They played with fire, and then they got burned. This isn't a 2007 or 2008 situation where the fire spread and hurt someone else: this disaster is almost entirely "contained" to only the circle of reckless players.
You make a good point. I completely forgot that part. Kindof important too.
It's kind of fuzzy just how much of it was leveraged, but there's more clarity into the situation of the family office in this article -- https://www.ft.com/content/c319839d-d185-4e8a-bbc7-659bebe58...