Some math is needed here, but intuition tells me 20% of X companies is more than 1% of X + Y companies, Y being those who decide to evade taxes by being incorporated in Ireland.
I could be completely wrong, I’m not a tax lawyer
For a "fair" scheme they would tax on their share of revenue.
Irish GDP is about 2.5% of EU GDP. 20% of 2.5% is 0.5%
So with the current scheme they make double.
And yes, that calculation is wrong in many ways. On the one side the current GDP is increased due to the tax business (they are 1% of population) on the other hand there are still many company's not doing the Irish game. And yes, I ignored the Dutch for this calculation ...