Firstly, the “underlying [PoW] protocol” assumes the “majority of CPU power is controlled by nodes that are not cooperating to attack the network” (Satoshi, 2009). IOW “Bitcoin” is defined as the chain with the highest cumulative hashing power. That assumption is baked into all PoW networks.
Secondly, Jude C. Nelson — who you seem to have a professional/academic disagreement with — has a PhD in distributed systems from Princeton. I’m not saying your disagreement with Jude deserves no credibility, but I’m also not prepared to give a pseudonyous commenter on HN the same weight.
(JCN runs circles around Vitalik Buterin — a highly entertaining read [1].)
The 2013 bitcoin-0.7 BDB chainsplit incident you’ve propped up as “proof” PoW lacks a fork ranking protocol — which it doesn’t — was ultimately resolved with hashpower (of course). Humans only got involved there to prevent needless network downtime, read: “Eventually 24 blocks would be lost”. The incident would’ve eventually resolved itself on-chain by PoW miners, with hashing power only.
> I'm not saying [PoS] is better by the way... they're all the same.
Proof-of-Stake consensus lacks all notion of cumulative hashrate, and altogether lacks a quantitative fork ranking protocol. To claim PoS and PoW are “the same” in this respect is simply false equivalence.
PoS systems undeniably lack an on-chain mechanism for resolving fork disputes. Hence they have little need for a blockchain — after all, if a top-down human hierarchy presiding over a blockchain is going to unilaterally decide which chainfork to favor anyway, they might as well just skip the blockchain and use Git. As with Git repos, in PoS, forking disputes have to be handled by centralized authorities who outright dictate which Git history is valid. No other dispute resolution protocols are possible here.
Conversely, PoW systems make this determination by ranking cumulative hashing power amongst forked blockchains. PoW networks coldly and quantitatively come to consensus about what constitutes the longest valid chain. PoS systems use less energy than PoW systems, but they can’t even come to consensus without top-down hierarchical human intervention under adversarial conditions, hence they have little reason to use a blockchain at all.