2. Terrorism has similarly precise definitions, usually along the lines of "the act has to be in pursuit of political aims". Just because its a big and important target does not make it political, ransomware is an economic crime.
For anyone with time on their hands, the "Talinn Manual" has a lot of detail on this:
https://www.kobo.com/ie/en/ebook/tallinn-manual-2-0-on-the-i...
You could but you probably would lose that bet. This has been done for decades now, especially between friendly countries (see https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/eu-mi6-brexit...) without any sort of repercussion.
Diplomatic posturing aside ("We will treat any intrusion attempt on our networks as an agression"), literally no government actually wants to go to war over a hack.
> Given the recent pipeline issue and its national security implications I am not going to be surprised at all if some hackers in Russia end up dead from 'accidents' that are so obviously not accidents that no one is fooled.
This is even more nonsensical. Certainly governments would benefit way more from hiring those hackers and/or buying vulns from them than killing them. Especially in less-friendly countries like Russia.
The war started more than a decade ago. Like the Cold War that preceded it, there is little value in pretending the conflict does not exist nor that escalation is impossible.
well, this is not just an "hack" this blocks the entire national healthcare IT, it could cost lives.
Of course I knew what you were talking about; the war media has been beating this drum for at least a week even though it was obvious from the start that Colonial do shit work and grasp at any straw to excuse that. Anyone who wants to see more of that CYA bullshit can find plenty to see, so your jingoistic and warmongering comment has no place in this thread. Foment war among nuclear powers elsewhere.
What a complete waste of time it is discussing anything on HN that you touch.
You might want to ask the "actual" [?] "professionals" who "specialize in attribution" whether attribution has anything to do with this episode. (Not the episode in TFA, remember, but rather the one you decided [for political reasons?] to talk about instead.) You concede that Darkside are the authors of the hack, and credit at least some of their communication about it. What attribution remains to be done? The actual expertise in attribution among computer security professionals is in identifying and profiling tools and techniques. The amateur psychology and geopolitical analysis we sometimes see quoted in the war media as "attribution" is just bullshit.
If you're in this thread discussing TFA which does not contain the string "Russia" for the obvious reasons, then you are indeed wasting your time. If you're just trying to clear up some intellectually debilitating confusion, then please continue the discussion.
This is not true. For example major countries like the United States and the United Kingdom are not nation states but can still commit acts of war under international law.