Income is not the rate of change of wealth. Wealth can appreciate significantly without being reflected in taxable income.
Income is not the rate of change of wealth. Wealth can appreciate significantly without being reflected in taxable income.
Right at the top the terminology clearly delineates the two:
> These economists have been seeking to measure income inequality and wealth inequality, and to understand the nature of the 1 percent’s income and assets.
I read it before I posted, and I think that by presenting wealth and income together, they are conflating them. The terminology is nice, but it is not backed up by the content.
For example how much of the wealth comes from income? I imagine a significant portion has not been recognized. Someone could be self-made and have billions in wealth but only a fraction of that has been recognized as income.
Change in overall net worth - consumption
It seems there are so many ways to capture what "wealthy" really means. Some edge cases that challenge my understanding of wealthy:1. I could make and spend $1m/year and have a net worth of $0.
2. I could earn $1m/year and consume $20k
2.1 I could donate the difference and have a net worth change of $0
2.2 I could save/invest the difference and grow my wealth
3. I could make $1m and have my $1m investments go to $0, leaving no change in my net worth (aside from that year's consumption)
4. I could make $0 and have my investments grow by $1m
5. I could have a net worth of $0 but earn $1m/year
6. I could make $10m/year but have my $100m investments go down to $50m, leaving me $40m poorer, but still be both a high earner and high net worth individual.
Also, debt factors in to these.
All of these variables move, and the definition of "rich" seems to be an ill-defined function of: - Income (from all sources) - Net worth - net worth change - Consumption/lifestyle - Debt - Other (connections, access to capital, creditworthiness)
I wonder how much overlap there even is between the top .01% Wealth households and .01% income without capital gains.
The “income” 0.01% are going to be people like lottery winners and are wholely unrepresentative.
It would be great if consumption and not income could be taxed though (not easy).
Calculating wealth is hard, but they already do that. If you have numbers for wealth over time, take the rate of change.
They calculated "Wealth" for this article.
There are many many valuation methods for assets, including art, and each has its trade offs (yes they can be gamed). Unless you want to take this to its philosophical conclusion of no observation being able to be an objective truth.
Plus as much as I want it I just don't see how would you ever implement anything practical. Pure sophistication and obfuscation helps hide the wealth. Somebody rick can easily spend 10% of their wealth doing that (we're talking millions here) and tracing back these paths can turn out to be more expensive. Gov is at huge disadvantage here despite laws already helping it in a very questionable ways - like your need to prove where did you get some money from instead of gov proving that you got it illegally.
An exception could perhaps be made for sale on the death of the registered owner, and sale to public galleries.
Not taxable income, but still income, isn’t it?