Even without the complicity, stopping fraud and bad behavior is a difficult problem. Part time reviewers and reputation seem woefully insufficient counters.
Even without the complicity, stopping fraud and bad behavior is a difficult problem. Part time reviewers and reputation seem woefully insufficient counters.
Can you imagine how annoying this would be? How much time you would spend simply explaining to these people what your code does, so they could understand the basics of what your program is even doing? How ineffective they would be at detecting actual fraud, and how quickly their processes would turn into yet another annoying layer of bureaucracy and checklist compliance?
There are a lot of things Universities could do to assist scientists in producing better output. This is not one of them.
We forget all the not quite as awful things that were just let slide and normalized.
1) If people realize it's more like a Facebook post, that will be better. People will be able to push back.
2) Alternatively, if we clean up this mess, that will be even better. Academia ought to be trustworthy.
I don't see a path to #2 without a lot of dishonest people with tenure being laid off. At elite institutions, most people hired in the past decade or two cheated at least a little bit. I don't see a path to get there without a high-profile scandal.