I've been using it for more than 3 years and have noticed lots of duplicates in searches like you mention, but the flagging feature has removed virtually all crappy songs. I bump in to way fewer of these types of tracks now than in 2008 when it was called Grooveshark Lite. The vast majority of songs are great quality. But I agree, there are lots of duplicates and bad tagging around.
Another upside to user uploaded content is that Grooveshark has a massive library of available songs. I have found the most obscure artists in different languages on Grooveshark. I listen to a lot of music and artists and there are very few musicians I haven't found on Grooveshark.