> But imagine that we forced lots of people to sell shares every April to pay for their gains. There’d be more sellers than buyers as everyone raced to raise cash, and prices would go down, and our collective wealth with it. No one really wants this. (To the degree that anyone wants it, it would be the rich — as they have the collective borrowing power to buy back shares on the cheap while poorer folks can’t.)
Such a scheme shouldn’t introduce an imbalance: with how liquid and efficient the stock market is, these exchanges would be known about well in advance and easy profits would be arbitraged away. It’s like saying that stocks of hot dog makers peak near the Fourth of July.
Now, this is a valid concern for illiquid assets, but:
1) The previous paragraph makes clear the argument refers to the stock market, and
2) It’s not fair to compare the most naive, reckless way of assessing a wealth tax, which forces such sales of hard to value assets.